I am using a EL1300G-02W computer as a HTPC using MythTv.
It would play back 720p HD video just fine with the original processor, but couldn’t quite commercial flag new recordings in real-time while also watching a live feed. [This wasn’t a big issue, as I very rarely watch new recordings live.]
Even though it works working perfectly fine as a MythTV box with the original processor, I had been keeping an eye open on Ebay for a replacement X2 (dual core) processor for the AM2 socket.
I was limited to CPU’s that produced 45W or less of power, which basically means the “e” line ( 4450e, 5050e, 4850e, BE-2400, 3250e). These types of processors had been selling for $50-60, but then I lucked out and found an an AMD Athlon X2 BE-2400 2.3 GHz Processor which I was able to get cheaper than average ($32 w/ shipping!).
I decided that $32 (plus some thermal paste I already owned) was cheap enough to upgrade the CPU even though I didn’t really need the extra horsepower right now. The upgrade procedure was very painless. After removing four spring mounted screws that held the heat-sync and fan on top of the original processor, I lifted the ZIF socket lever, pulled out the old CPU, put in the new CPU, spread some new thermal paste on the heat-sync, and reversed my steps to put the fan and heat-sync back on. Total time: 5 minutes. When I powered the computer back on everything was recognized and working right off the bat, and I had plenty of extra CPU power for running simultaneous transcode and commercial flagging jobs.
The new CPU (Athlon X2 BE-2400) had the same sizes of L1 and L2 cache as the old one, (Athlon 2650e), but the memory throughput was higher (18GB/sec vs. 12GB/sec on the L1 and 3.5GB/sec vs. 2.4GB/sec on the L2). It was also able to access the 2GB of main memory at DDR 924 (462MHz – 2625 MB/sec) instead of DDR803 (401MHz – 2065MB/sec).
Power impact: The BE-2400 CPU takes more power (of course!) raising the idle power usage of the computer from 25 watts to 30 watts, and also significantly raises the maximum power usage (from 40 watts to 65 watts) when the CPU is running full tilt on both cores.
I don’t mind raising the maximum ceiling 15 watts, as I rarely run the CPU at maximum, and with the faster/dual cpu’s, it should finish jobs more quickly (possibly more efficiently overall). I have decided that a continuous 5 watt penalty (when sitting idle) isn’t a bad price to pay for having (around 3X) extra horsepower around should I need it. Being able to finish ripping a CD or DVD quickly, or commercial flag two recordings at once, although not a requirement, is a nice advantage.
Jay,
This is helpful — just ran across your blog today when searching for ideas on how to speed up my EL1300G system. Got mine refurbished from TigerDirect and have been pleased overall.
Was trying to solve the issue of HD video streaming– frame rate when streaming with silverlight or hulu in HD isn’t quite there. Do you notice an improvement in this area or would this be a graphics chipset limitation that couldn’t be overcome by a faster processor?
Finally, if you don’t mind, I have a few more questions…
What OS are you using on your system?
Do you mind sharing where you found your BE-2400 for such a great price, or was it a special one-off situation?
What’s the rest of your HTPC setup like? I am putting together a Windows Home Server system with all my media on it, and I’m on Win 7 on all PC’s. XBMC seems like a great interface; while I’m an intermediate tecchie, I’m a newbie when it comes to HTPC builds and am trying to figure out what to do.
Thanks much –
Ken
Hi Ken,
I’m using Ubuntu Linux. I haven’t tried using the new processor under windows, so I can’t comment for sure, but I’m almost 100% positive that that it would be able to playback Hulu content much better than your current processor.
I watched about 30 CPU’s sell on E-Bay before finding the BE-2400 at a lower than average price.
I’m using MythTV running on Linux for my PVR setup, with a Silicon Dust HDHomerun network (Ethernet) tuner (which I recommend, it works with windows media center as well as Linux).
Jay
Jay,
I recently upgraded my el1300 using a athlon be-2350 2.1 Ghz processor and was wondering what your idle temperature is. I have gotten a reading of 50c with no load and wondering if that is a safe temp to be running at before putting a full load on it. I put the stock heatsink back on it but was concerned abot the temp since 78c is the processors fail/safe point. Thanks
Jim,
That temp sounds somewhat high for idle operation. I am running Linux and not entirely 100% sure that I am measuring my CPU temp (and not some other MB sensor) but I’m seeing a 30c temp from my idle system on my k8temp-hwmon1 sensor.
Did you add thermal paste when you re-used your original heat sync & fan?
Jay
well upon inspecting how my thermal grease was doing i see that the middle of the processor was not being protected with compound. so i reapplied using the line method and temps are now around 35-40c. not sure wht the grease was not in the middle of the processor since that is where I did my pea sized drop. but all is fixed. thanks
I put the 4850e in mine and it idles around 45-50c. You run anything and it get to hot. Gonna try a different cooler.
Dave were you able to find a different cooler an how did it work out thank’s